Understanding Sibling Rivalry & How to Heal
Adult sibling rivalry is one of the most misunderstood forms of family conflict. While we often expect childhood competition to fade with age, many people find that the emotional wounds and old dynamics don’t disappear just because they grow up. In fact, those unresolved tensions can evolve into deeper forms of resentment, silence, or even estrangement in adulthood.
So why does adult sibling rivalry still hurt so much? Because those early roles;
the responsible one
the golden child
the troublemaker
often follow us into adulthood, whether we realize it or not. And when those identities become fixed, they can prevent authentic connection and reinforce cycles of comparison, judgment, and emotional distance.
The Legacy of Childhood Roles
From a young age, siblings often get labeled in ways that serve the family structure, not necessarily the child’s development. Maybe one sibling was praised for being obedient while another was criticized for being emotional or high-energy. These roles aren’t always negative, but they often become restrictive.
The smart one. The sensitive one. The screw-up. The helper.
Labels like these may have helped parents manage a chaotic household, but they came at a cost. Children internalize these roles and often continue to play them well into adulthood, even if unconsciously.
When childhood roles go unexamined, they harden into identities. And over time, these identities create invisible walls between siblings who might otherwise be close.
How These Roles Show Up in Adulthood
The pain of adult sibling rivalry often emerges when one sibling tries to grow beyond their role, and the other doesn’t recognize or accept that growth. For example:
The "troublemaker" who becomes a successful entrepreneur is still treated like the family failure.
The "golden child" feels immense pressure to maintain the image and resents their siblings for not understanding it.
The "peacemaker" avoids conflict at all costs, even when boundaries are needed.
These unspoken dynamics often fuel resentment, jealousy, and emotional disconnection, even if no one openly talks about it.
What makes it even harder? These roles are usually reinforced not just by siblings, but by parents and extended family members who continue to view everyone through the old lens.
Emotional Triggers in Adult Sibling Conflict
Sibling rivalry in adulthood rarely looks like childish bickering. It shows up in more subtle and painful ways:
Feeling invisible during family gatherings
Competing for parental approval or attention, even unconsciously
Assuming the worst about each other’s intentions
Feeling judged based on outdated perceptions
Experiencing guilt or obligation rather than authentic closeness
Because family roles are so deeply ingrained, even small interactions can trigger big emotions. One passive-aggressive comment or dismissive tone can bring up years of pain.
Why Adult Sibling Rivalry Is So Painful
You might expect that time, maturity, or life experience would soften these conflicts, and sometimes they do. But when rivalry persists, it often cuts deeper than other types of relationship conflict. Here's why:
It challenges your identity. If your sibling sees you only as your past role, it feels like they’re denying your growth.
It threatens your sense of belonging. Sibling dynamics are rooted in your earliest attachments. When those bonds feel shaky, your emotional foundation can too.
It’s often ignored. Society tends to dismiss sibling conflict as less important than romantic or parental relationships. But the pain is real and lasting.
Being misunderstood or dismissed by someone who shares your history can be uniquely painful. It can leave you questioning your worth, your memories, and your place in the family.
The Role of Parents in Sustaining Rivalry
Parents don’t always mean to play favorites, but their words, decisions, and attention can reinforce sibling roles well into adulthood. A parent might consistently turn to the same child in times of crisis, regularly praise one sibling’s achievements while overlooking another’s, or rely on one sibling for support while assuming others won’t step up.
Even well-intentioned parents can deepen rivalry when they lean on old dynamics instead of seeing their adult children as individuals.
These behaviors often go unspoken, but their emotional impact is felt deeply. Over time, siblings internalize these patterns, adding another layer of tension to their relationships.
What Healing Looks Like
Healing adult sibling rivalry requires acknowledging the invisible scripts you’ve both been following. It means making space for new ways of relating, not based on the past, but on who you are now.
This healing journey starts with self-reflection. Ask yourself what role you were assigned and how it shaped your identity. Reflect on what parts of that role still linger in your adult relationships. Naming the dynamic can be powerful, even if it’s awkward. Saying something like, “I think we still interact based on how things were when we were kids,” can shift the conversation.
Healing also requires letting go of the need to win. It’s not about whose pain is bigger or more justified. It’s about listening and offering compassion for one another’s truth. From there, setting new boundaries helps redefine how you engage moving forward, whether that’s about communication styles, emotional topics, or time spent together.
In many cases, sibling therapy provides the support and structure needed to do this work, either individually or together. It can be a space to process unresolved grief, shift long-held beliefs, and build new patterns based on mutual respect.
Why It’s Worth Doing the Work
Adult sibling relationships have the potential to be deeply supportive, healing, and meaningful. Unlike friendships, they are rooted in shared history. Unlike romantic relationships, they often endure life changes and distance.
But that potential can only be realized when the rivalry is addressed and the old roles are retired.
When adult siblings are able to see each other as they are today, not who they were decades ago, something powerful happens. Space opens up for real connection. Humor can return. Compassion replaces competition.
Even if your sibling never fully comes to the table, doing this work for yourself can free you from the emotional weight of being defined by your past.
Letting Go of the Roles That No Longer Serve You
You don’t have to stay the "black sheep," the "overachiever," or the "invisible one."
You are not obligated to keep performing the role your family assigned you.
And neither is your sibling.
Letting go of these labels creates space for growth, healing, and an adult relationship built on choice, not expectation.
If you’re struggling with adult sibling rivalry, therapy can help you:
Explore emotional patterns
Reshape communication
Heal from long-standing relational pain
These shifts don’t just improve your sibling dynamic, they can positively affect how you see yourself.
Sibling rivalry doesn’t have to define your relationship forever. With intention, honesty, and support, you can start to outgrow the patterns of the past and redefine what your sibling bond looks like today.
Author
MEET THE SBCS TEAM
At Space Between Counseling Services (SBCS), we're a team of diverse therapists passionate about enriching your mental health through insightful articles. Licensed across MD, NM, DE, DC (District of Columbia), and FL, we blend expertise in anxiety, depression, trauma, and more, striving for inclusivity in every piece we write.
Our collective voice aims to guide, educate, and support you through modern life's complexities.